Short answer: pick your first two marketing channels by scoring every candidate on four things: whether your buyers already look there, what a first test costs, how fast it gives a signal, and whether the channel’s economics fit your deal size. Run two channels properly for 60 to 90 days. Five channels run badly teach you nothing.
Most founders I talk to have already tried four or five channels. A bit of LinkedIn, a Meta campaign for two weeks, a newsletter, one cold email sequence. Nothing worked, so they conclude marketing doesn’t work for them. What actually happened is that no channel got enough budget, time or attention to produce a readable result.
The fix is a choice made on paper before any money moves. Here is the scoring model I use with clients, and the reasoning behind each criterion.
Why two channels and not five?
Two is the number a small team can run well, and it gives you one comparison. With one channel you can’t tell whether a bad result comes from the channel or from your offer. With two you can often see the difference: if both underperform the same way, the problem sits in the offer or the page. If one works and one doesn’t, you have a channel signal.
With five channels, each one gets a fifth of the budget and a fifth of someone’s week. A cold email sequence needs a few hundred contacts and a month of follow-ups before the reply rate means anything. A search campaign needs enough clicks to see which queries convert. Splitting a small budget five ways leaves each test below the noise floor, and you end up deciding by gut feeling anyway.
How do you score a channel?
Score each candidate from 1 to 5 on four criteria, then add them up. Be honest and write one sentence of evidence per score. If you can’t write the sentence, the score is a guess, and a guess gets a 2.
| Criterion | The question | Score 5 means | Score 1 means |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer presence | Do my buyers already look for a solution here? | They search or ask for vendors in this exact place | They never go there for work decisions |
| Cost to test | What does a readable first test cost? | Under a few hundred dollars or a week of your time | Needs a large budget or a full-time hire |
| Time to signal | How fast will I know if it works? | Replies or leads within two to three weeks | Nothing measurable for six months |
| Economic fit | Does the cost per lead make sense at my deal size? | Cost per lead is a small fraction of first-year revenue per customer | One customer would not repay the cost of ten leads |
A channel scoring 16 or more is a real candidate. Below 12, drop it for now. Between the two, it is a second-wave channel.
What does “economic fit” mean in practice?
It means checking the arithmetic before you spend. If a click costs $4 on a channel and a typical page converts a small percentage of visitors into leads, you can estimate cost per lead on the back of an envelope. Then ask how many leads become customers and what a customer is worth in the first year. If the result is a customer that costs more to win than they pay, the channel is wrong for you at that price point, however good the targeting looks.
This is why a $200 product and a $20,000 contract rarely share a first channel. Paid social suits a low-ticket product bought on impulse. A long B2B sale usually needs outbound, search or referrals, where one conversation can carry the cost. For current click costs, the CPC by industry data and the LinkedIn ads benchmarks give you a starting range for the envelope math.
What did this look like on real projects?
On a Series A B2B SaaS entering a new segment, the team had been spread across content, events and a few paid experiments. We rebuilt the ICP first, then narrowed to two channels: automated content operations and a validated outbound motion. MQLs went from 14 to 39 a month in 60 days, CAC payback shortened from 9 to 5 months, and outbound replies ran at 11%. The gain came from concentrating effort, not from finding a magic channel.
Parquet, a floor restoration company in Paris, is the opposite case. There was no ad budget at all, so the scoring made the answer easy: search was the only channel with a cost to test near zero and buyers who were already looking. We built a topical cluster of 228 articles and an automated lead qualification flow. First leads came within 30 days, CAC was €0, and revenue reached €12K by month three. A channel’s score depends on your constraints, and a zero budget is a constraint like any other. The Parquet case has the details.
What do you do after you pick two?
- Write down the success threshold before you start: for example, a target number of qualified conversations in 60 days.
- Set a fixed test budget and a fixed weekly time block per channel, and don’t move money between them mid-test.
- Track one number per channel: cost per qualified lead, not clicks or impressions.
- At day 60 to 90, keep the channel that beat the threshold, fix or kill the other, and add the next channel from your scored list.
The hard part is leaving the other three channels alone. Someone will tell you that you must be on TikTok or that email is dead. Check their claim against your own scoring table. If your buyers are not on that platform, the claim doesn’t apply to you.
What are the common mistakes?
The first is choosing a channel because a competitor is visible there. Visibility tells you where they spend, not where they get customers. The second is picking by personal preference: founders who like writing choose content, founders who like calls choose outbound. Preference is a fine tie-breaker, but only after the scores. The third is judging a channel before it has had a fair test, usually in the first two weeks of a search or SEO effort.
I’d add a fourth: skipping the offer. If neither channel works, check the offer and the landing page before blaming the channels. A weak offer looks identical across every channel.
FAQ
Can I start with only one channel?
Yes, if budget is very tight. Accept that you’ll have less information, and add the second channel as soon as the first produces a stable result.
How long should I run a channel before judging it?
Paid search and outbound give a usable signal in three to six weeks. SEO and content need several months. Compare each against its own timeline, not against the fastest channel.
Is organic social a good first channel?
It can be, if your buyers follow people like you and you have the time to post consistently. It scores low on time to signal for most companies, so pair it with something faster.